Brininger LTD MAY 2002 ERISA CASE SUMMARIES

© 2003 Brininger LTD All rights reserved.

Please read our Copyright Notice and Disclaimers before you use this resource.

Supreme Court

First Circuit

 

Second Circuit

 

Third Circuit

 

Fourth Circuit

Fifth Circuit

 

Sixth Circuit

 

 

Seventh Circuit

Eighth Circuit

.


 

Ninth Circuit

Helm v. Sun Life Assurance of Canada, Inc., 2002 WL 726487 (9th Cir. Apr. 24, 2002) (unpublished)- Here, the Policy provides that long-term disability benefits will be paid upon Sun Life's receipt of "written proof," and "[t]he proof, which must be satisfactory to us, is to be given to us at our Office."  The Policy also states that proof in connection with the terms or benefits of the Policy may be required, and "[i]f proof is required, we must be provided with such evidence satisfactory to us as we may reasonably require under the circumstances

We conclude that the Policy in the instant case unambiguously provides that the plan administrator has the discretion to grant or deny claims.

Tenth Circuit

Eleventh Circuit

D.C. Circuit

 

Up Table of Contents Blair Brininger Biography Brief Bank ERISA Brief Bank ERISA Summaries ERISA Litigation SEARCH THE SITE ltdclaims.blogspot.com